Baltimore Judge Orders Partial New Trial for Ex-Priest in 1990s Abuse Case
A circuit court judge vacated two of five convictions against William Mannion Jr. because he had not yet started his job at the school when those specific crimes allegedly occurred.
By Tomas Gonzalez ·

Circuit Judge Dennis Robinson Jr. granted a former Catholic priest a new trial on two of five child sex abuse counts on Tuesday, a split decision that leaves three convictions in place and moves the case toward sentencing.
A jury at Baltimore County Circuit Court found William Mannion Jr. guilty on Oct. 8 of one count of child abuse and four counts of second-degree sex offense. His legal team, Charles Waechter and Christopher Luber, argued that the jury verdict was contrary to the evidence. Robinson ruled that the evidence proved Mannion began working at St. Agnes Catholic School in Catonsville after the period alleged for two of the second-degree sex offenses.
The judge allowed the verdicts on the remaining three counts to stand. Prosecutors will set a sentencing date for Dec. 14. Deputy State’s Attorney Lisa Dever dropped the two contested counts rather than seeking a retrial, though it remains unclear if that change will affect the final sentence.
Prosecutors allege that Mannion, 64, of Sparrows Point, repeatedly removed a student and altar server from class to sexually assault him in the rectory during school hours. The survivor testified that the abuse ended when his family relocated out of state.
Mannion left the priesthood in 1998. He later married and became a father. He worked as a case manager at Johns Hopkins Bayview Medical Center before transitioning to a role as a nurse in the psychiatric unit.
The case created a divide within the local Catholic community. Some parishioners noted that Mannion helped expose John Merzbacher, a notorious child rapist who taught at the Catholic Community School of Baltimore and victimized dozens of children. Merzbacher died in 2023 while serving four life sentences.
Mannion is currently held at the Baltimore County Detention Center while he awaits sentencing.






