Chicago Police Rarely Execute Gun Seizure Orders for Domestic Violence Survivors
Since a state law took effect last year, officers have only completed three of 91 court-ordered searches to remove firearms from alleged abusers.
By Julian Schulz ·

Survivors of domestic violence in Chicago are waiting for protection that the city’s police force rarely delivers. Under the Karina Law, judges can order officers to search homes and seize guns from alleged abusers. Yet, since the law took effect, the Chicago Police Department has executed only three of those orders.
Court records show that judges have issued 91 such orders in cases involving the Karina Law. In just three instances, police conducted the searches. In each of those three cases, officers found firearms. One search in Bridgeport yielded 26 guns during a criminal case in July. Another in July recovered two weapons, and a third in October found four. The remaining 88 orders were not executed.
Dominique, 26, sought a protective order and a search warrant after her ex-boyfriend pointed a gun at her head this summer. A judge granted the warrant, giving police 96 hours to act. Two days later, an officer convinced the judge to void the order. Dominique told the court, “I just don’t want to die.” Her lawyer, Mallory Morgan, argued the officer’s claim that the gun might have moved was weak given the recent threat.
Legal Aid Chicago attorney Benna Crawford noted that the department relies on a “system of honor” where abusers voluntarily turn in guns. Crawford said this approach undermines the law’s intent. She added that when clients sought orders against suburban police agencies, those agencies complied and recovered weapons in every instance. In contrast, Chicago police have not executed a single order for more than 30 of Legal Aid’s clients since May.
The Karina Law went into effect on May 11, 2025. It was named after Karina González, who was shot by her husband in 2023 despite having a protection order. The law requires police to have 96 hours to execute a search if a recent police report exists, or 48 hours to investigate and object if not. A police spokesperson said the department does not refuse searches but strengthens pre-compliance checks to ensure safety. State Senator Celina Villanueva, a key sponsor of the law, called the low execution rate a problem that needs review.
Violence statistics show that while domestic violence homicides have declined, non-fatal shootings have risen. This year, 69 people in Chicago were shot by a domestic partner, a 25% increase over the same period in 2025. Police officials acknowledge the challenge of verifying information quickly. Christopher Papaioannou, a finalist for police superintendent, said officers sometimes struggle to corroborate details and assess risks within the tight timeline. The department says most guns are recovered through voluntary compliance, but advocates argue this leaves survivors in the dark.






