Experts Debate Post-Midterm Strategy
Panelists at Johns Hopkins discuss how Democrats can govern with limited seats while Republicans face internal pressure to adapt after election losses.
By Tomas Gonzalez ·

The SNF Agora Institute at Johns Hopkins University hosted a panel on November 5, two days after the midterm elections, to analyze the political fallout. The discussion was moderated by Tom Hall, a Visiting Fellow at the institute. He clarified that the views expressed by the panelists did not necessarily reflect the official position of the university. The group included former Maryland Senator Ben Cardin and former Representative John Sarbanes, along with faculty members Lilliana Mason and Scott Warren.
Cardin noted that Democrats currently hold approximately 250 House seats, a number that allows for partisan lawmaking. However, he cautioned against relying solely on this majority because partisan bills often have short lifespans. He pointed to the One Big Beautiful Bill Act as an example of legislation that includes scheduled expiration dates due to budgetary strategies. Instead, he argued that Democrats need to build support across party lines to address affordability and maintain accountability.
Sarbanes identified affordability and accountability as the primary priorities for incoming Democratic senators. He broke down affordability into income and expense factors. On the income side, he suggested raising the minimum wage. On the expense side, he proposed making healthcare more accessible through the Affordable Care Act and restoring Medicaid funding. He also cited price gouging as a major issue, noting that companies raised oil prices excessively when the Iran War began. He argued that transparency could force companies to lower prices through public pressure or stricter regulation.
Mason observed that the unexpected Democratic gains in traditionally Republican states offer a chance to shift public perception through storytelling. She stated that emotions drive political engagement more than facts. “Storytelling is how people understand anything,” Mason said. She added that when people feel emotional, facts often fail to change their minds, and politics is primarily driven by these emotional responses.
Warren questioned whether the election results signal a permanent shift in conservative values or simply a temporary disillusionment with government. He noted that many Republicans voted against their own party, while Democrats won by large margins. This suggests that many voters feel disconnected from both major parties. “Americans don’t feel like institutions are working for them, and there’s nothing about this election that's changed that,” Warren explained.
The panel also addressed the role of the Senate filibuster. Cardin described the tactic as a procedural tool used to delay votes, noting that it is often abused by both parties. He predicted that changes to the rule would be gradual. Sarbanes shared that a filibuster blocked his 2019 proposal, the For the People Act, which aimed to fix gerrymandering and limit the influence of money in politics. He argued that voting should be a simple process rather than an obstacle course.
The conversation turned to the Republican Party’s future after its electoral losses. Speaker Mike Johnson announced he will not run for minority leader, leaving Steve Scalise and Jim Jordan as potential candidates. Mason noted that it often takes multiple losses for a party to change its tactics. She pointed to the 2012 Republican defeat, after which the party pledged moderate positions before nominating Donald Trump in 2016. She does not expect this single loss to immediately alter Republican strategies.
The session concluded with a Q and A segment where attendees asked about the House size and potential Supreme Court appointments. Cardin stated that Congress could block new justice appointments if Justices Alito and Thomas retired before the new Congress was sworn in on January 3. He believed President Trump would likely ignore that power. In a separate interview, second-year student Camila Botello expressed uncertainty about how youth support for the Democratic Party would hold up in the coming months.






