Sotomayor: Midterms Check Executive Power
The justice argued that voters acted as a safeguard after the Supreme Court granted presidents broad criminal immunity.
By Tomas Gonzalez ·

Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor stated on Friday that her colleagues may view the recent midterm elections as a necessary check on presidential power. Speaking in Philadelphia, she addressed the implications of the court’s recent ruling on executive immunity.
When asked if justices relied on elections as an institutional safeguard when granting Trump and former presidents broad criminal immunity, Sotomayor answered "absolutely." She argued that the justices believe voters can correct executive actions through the ballot box.
"My colleagues today would probably applaud the last election, because they believe that if the people don’t like what’s happening, they can speak with their vote," Sotomayor said. "And they did speak."
She added that while the justices might not have liked the specific outcome of the election, they structurally believed that voting protects the public against executive excess. Sotomayor has previously criticized the 6-3 decision, stating she hopes it will be overturned.
During a 45-minute discussion at an American Philosophical Society event, Sotomayor continued to condemn the ruling. She argued that her colleagues missed a fundamental principle of American law.
"I think what they missed was the concept that there was no man in this country, and I use the male version, because that’s the saying, that no man was above the law here," she said. She noted that this principle was always a key factor in how executives made decisions.
Sotomayor did not shut down talk of Supreme Court term limits when asked by an audience member. She said the decision rests with elected officials and pointed to other countries that use age or term limits instead of lifetime appointments.






