Kamehameha Schools seeks dismissal of Native Hawaiian admission lawsuit
The private institution argues that making tuition free for the 2026-2027 school year eliminates the contract dispute cited by plaintiffs.
By Tomas Gonzalez ·

Kamehameha Schools asked a federal judge on Tuesday to dismiss a lawsuit challenging its admission policy for Native Hawaiians. The school’s legal team contends that the case should end because the institution eliminated the specific contract dispute raised by the plaintiffs by making tuition free for the 2026 to 2027 academic year.
Students for Fair Admissions (SFFA), a conservative legal advocacy group, filed the suit last year. The organization argues that the school’s preference for Native Hawaiian students is unconstitutional and constitutes racial discrimination. The lawsuit arrived weeks after SFFA launched a campaign to test the legality of the policy.
Judge Micah Smith of the U.S. District Court heard arguments from both sides in a packed courtroom. Attorney John Bash represented Kamehameha Schools. He argued that the plaintiffs lack standing, or the legal right to sue, for two main reasons. First, the free tuition policy resolved the contractual issue. Second, two unidentified families in the lawsuit have not applied to the school, and their intent to apply remains unclear.
The school was founded in 1887 under the will of Princess Bernice Pauahi Bishop during a sharp decline in the Hawaiian population. A five-member Board of Trustees governs the institution and oversees assets valued at approximately $15 billion. The board also manages the Estate of Bernice Pauahi Bishop.
Supporters of the school, including students, community advocates, and trustees, filled the courtroom during the hearing. Tyler Iokepa Gomes, chief administrator of Kilohana at the Hawaiian Council and a 2005 graduate of the Kapālama campus, described the admission process as highly competitive. He noted that when he entered kindergarten, perhaps only one boy and one girl from the Kailua region were admitted. He expects demand to rise now that tuition is free in perpetuity.
Hinaleimoana Wong, also known as Kumu Hina and a school graduate, expressed confidence in the school’s case. She stated that Judge Smith, who is a son of Hawaiʻi, would weigh the realities of the local community heavily. Before the hearing, more than 100 people gathered in support at Kawaiahaʻo Plaza.
Crystal Rose, a trustee and attorney who previously represented the school in the 1990s, described the experience of watching the hearing from the defense side as difficult. She told the group that they stand united. Mason Fong, a current senior at the school, said students have a responsibility to speak up, noting that Princess Pauahi envisioned a future for them before they were born.
More Business · Consumer Watch · Report a business · Got a Story?






